I still remember the first time I opened a “premium increase” notice and felt my stomach drop. It was not long-term care insurance for me, it was another bill in my early paycheck-to-paycheck years. Same feeling, though: you planned for one number, and now the number changed.
If you already own a long-term care (LTC) insurance policy and the insurer raises your premium, you typically have a handful of choices. The best one depends on what you can afford today and what kind of protection you want to preserve for a future claim.

First, take a breath and gather the facts
Before you make a change, collect the policy details that determine how strong your coverage really is. Rate increase notices often come with a response deadline (it should be shown on the letter or your online account), and once you reduce benefits it can be difficult to restore them later. In many cases, increasing benefits again requires new underwriting, and it may not be available at all.
What to pull from the notice and your policy
- The new premium and when it starts.
- Your current daily or monthly benefit (example: $200 per day).
- Benefit period (example: 3 years, 5 years, 6 years, lifetime) or your total benefit pool (sometimes listed as a maximum lifetime benefit).
- Elimination period (example: 90 days). This usually does not change with a rate increase offer, but confirm.
- Inflation protection rider (example: 3% compound, 5% compound, simple inflation, or none).
- Any nonforfeiture provision already in the policy, plus what the company is offering as an alternative.
- Whether you are currently on claim. Some policies and some states handle on-claim policyholders differently, including how increases apply and what options you are offered.
Three benefit levers drive your payout
In plain English, your future payout is shaped by:
- How much you can receive per day or month (the cap).
- How long benefits can last (the bucket size, or total pool).
- How much that cap grows over time (inflation protection).
Most premium-increase options work by changing one or more of those levers.
Option 1: Pay more and keep coverage
This is the simplest option: you accept the increase and keep your daily benefit, benefit period or pool, and inflation protection unchanged.
What it means for a future claim
If you keep everything as-is, your future claim works exactly the way you planned when you bought the policy. That can be a big deal if you have strong inflation protection, since inflation riders can dramatically increase your benefit over the years.
When this tends to make sense
- You can afford the new premium without raiding emergency savings or running up credit cards.
- Your policy has valuable features you do not want to weaken (often a compound inflation rider or a longer benefit period).
- You are older and closer to the age when claims are more common, and you want maximum protection intact.
Budget reality check
If paying the higher premium means you will be late on other bills, under-save for retirement, or carry a credit card balance, that “keep it as-is” decision can backfire. LTC coverage is important, but it should not destabilize the rest of your plan.
Option 2: Lower the daily benefit
A very common way to offset a rate hike is to lower the benefit amount. Example: reducing a $200 per day benefit to $160 per day.
What it means for a future claim
Your policy will pay up to the new, lower limit, and you cover the rest. The exact mechanics vary by policy design. Some policies reimburse expenses up to a daily or monthly maximum. Others pay an indemnity or cash benefit. Some also pay different maximums for home care versus facility care.
Example: If your future assisted living cost averages $250 per day and your policy benefit is $160 per day, you may be responsible for the remaining $90 per day (assuming you meet benefit triggers and the policy pays up to a daily cap).
Pros
- Often preserves your benefit period or pool and inflation rider.
- Can be a predictable way to get the premium back to a manageable level.
Cons
- You are choosing a higher out-of-pocket share during a claim.
- If care costs in your area are already high, a lower cap can make the policy feel less helpful.

Option 3: Change inflation protection
If your policy includes inflation protection, changing it can significantly reduce premiums because inflation riders increase the insurer’s future expected payouts.
Common changes insurers may offer
- Drop from compound inflation to simple inflation.
- Drop from 5% compound to 3% compound.
- Remove inflation protection going forward.
What it means for a future claim
This is the option with the most “silent” impact. Your coverage may look fine on paper today, but 10 to 20 years from now it might not keep up with real care costs.
In plain terms: reducing inflation protection usually lowers what your daily or monthly benefit will be when you actually need care.
When it can be reasonable
- You bought the policy later in life and do not expect decades of inflation compounding before a likely claim.
- You already have a benefit amount that is high relative to costs in your area.
- You are trying to avoid cutting the benefit period or pool.
Watch-outs
- If you are younger (or just healthy and family longevity is strong), dropping compound inflation can be a big long-term sacrifice.
- Some policyholders change inflation protection, then get hit by another increase later. It is worth asking your insurer or agent what other adjustment options would remain in the future if that happens.
Option 4: Shorten the benefit period
Some LTC policies are structured as a pool (total benefit dollars), sometimes labeled a maximum lifetime benefit or benefit pool. Others show a benefit period. The math is similar: a shorter benefit period or smaller pool reduces how long the policy can pay.
What it means for a future claim
Your policy may still pay the same daily or monthly amount, but for fewer years. Once the pool is exhausted, benefits stop and you pay the full cost of care yourself.
Example: A $200 per day benefit for 3 years has a smaller total pool than a $200 per day benefit for 5 years. Cutting from 5 to 3 years can lower premiums, but it also increases the odds you will outlive the coverage if you have a long claim.
When this tends to make sense
- You primarily want protection against a medium-length care need, not an extended one.
- You have other resources you could use after the policy runs out.
- The alternative would be dropping the policy entirely.
Option 5: Use nonforfeiture benefits
“Nonforfeiture” is the insurance world’s way of saying: if you stop paying premiums, you do not walk away with nothing. Not every policy has it, and the form it takes varies by state and by contract.
How it usually works
Instead of continuing coverage with ongoing premiums, you convert what you have paid into a limited benefit. You may see this described as:
- Shortened benefit period (same daily benefit, fewer total days), or
- Reduced paid-up benefit (a paid-up policy with a smaller pool or daily benefit), or
- Return of premium features in some contracts.
What it means for a future claim
If you later qualify for benefits, the policy can still pay, but only up to the reduced amount created by the nonforfeiture option. Once that reduced pool is used up, benefits stop.
When this is a strong middle path
- You cannot afford the premium increase.
- You do not want to fully surrender the policy.
- You have paid into the policy for many years and want to preserve some meaningful protection.
Important: Ask for the nonforfeiture numbers in writing before choosing. You want to see the new daily benefit (if it changes), the total pool, and whether inflation protection continues or stops after the conversion.
Also ask: Do I qualify for contingent nonforfeiture (CNF) due to the size of this increase? In some states and policies, a large increase can trigger extra paid-up or reduced-benefit choices even if you did not originally buy a nonforfeiture rider.
Option 6: Reduced paid-up coverage
Reduced paid-up is a specific kind of conversion where you stop paying premiums and keep a paid-up policy with reduced benefits. Some companies offer it as part of nonforfeiture choices, and some use the label separately.
What it means for a future claim
You typically keep coverage, but the benefit is smaller than your original plan. The upside is that you no longer owe premiums, which removes the risk of future rate increases pricing you out.
Why people like this option
- No more premium bills, which can be a big stress reliever in retirement.
- You still have a defined pool to help with care costs.
Potential downsides
- The reduced benefit may be modest, especially if you have not held the policy long.
- Inflation protection may end or change, depending on the contract.

How each choice affects a claim
Here is the cleanest way to think about the trade-offs. The “best” choice is the one that protects the part of the benefit you are most likely to need.
| Your choice | What changes | Impact during a claim |
|---|---|---|
| Pay new premium | Nothing | Full planned benefit remains available |
| Lower daily or monthly benefit | Your payout cap | More out-of-pocket each day or month |
| Reduce inflation protection | How much your benefit grows over time | Lower benefit amount when you need care, especially if the claim is far in the future |
| Shorten benefit period or reduce pool | How long benefits can last | Coverage can run out sooner in a long claim |
| Nonforfeiture or reduced paid-up | Premiums stop, benefits reduce | Some coverage remains, but limited pool or lower benefit; no future premium increases |
| Drop the policy (lapse) | Coverage ends | No benefit available for a future claim unless a nonforfeiture or contingent nonforfeiture option applies |
Questions to ask before you decide
If you take nothing else from this page, take these questions. Call the insurer or your agent and get the answers in writing if possible.
- What will my new daily benefit be at age 80 (or 85) under each option? (This forces the inflation rider impact into real numbers.)
- Does my inflation protection continue after the change, and if so, at what rate and in what form?
- Is my policy reimbursement or indemnity, and is my cap daily or monthly? (This changes how the benefit actually pays.)
- What happens to my elimination period and any home care benefits? (Usually unchanged, but verify.)
- Is there a deadline to elect an alternative to the rate increase?
- If I choose reduced paid-up, is the policy truly paid-up with no future premiums due?
- If I reduce benefits now, can I increase them later without underwriting? (Often it requires underwriting, and it may not be available.)
- What is the exact total pool of money under each reduced option?
- Do I have shared care or a spousal shared pool provision, and does any change affect it?
- Do I qualify for contingent nonforfeiture due to this increase?
- Are any discounts available (spousal, multi-policy, association, or other), or is there a billing mode that helps cash flow (monthly versus annual)?
A simple way to choose
When I am helping a friend think this through, I try to avoid perfect math and focus on the highest-impact protection.
If you can, protect inflation
For many policyholders, especially if a claim is likely to be years away, inflation protection is what keeps a policy relevant. A daily benefit that looks decent today can feel small later.
If cash flow is tight, stop the bleeding
Rate increases can happen more than once. Locking in a reduced paid-up benefit removes the risk that future increases force you to lapse later, after paying even more in.
Adjust one lever at a time
For example, reducing the daily or monthly benefit or trimming inflation may be enough. Doing both can shrink the claim value faster than you expect.
Common mistakes after a rate hike
- Letting the policy lapse by accident. Missing the deadline can cost you options like nonforfeiture or contingent nonforfeiture elections.
- Cutting inflation protection without looking ahead. This is the quietest cut and the one people regret most.
- Comparing the new premium to today’s budget only. If you are retiring soon, ask whether the premium will still fit on your retirement income.
- Not asking for side-by-side option quotes. Insurers often can show multiple benefit adjustment packages. You want the menu, not one suggestion.
FAQ
Is a rate increase a sign my insurer is in trouble?
Not necessarily. In the U.S., long-term care insurance rate increases are typically subject to state insurance department review and approval. The practical question for you is simpler: what option preserves the best protection you can comfortably keep?
Can I shop my policy to another company instead of accepting the increase?
Switching typically means applying for a new policy, which can involve new underwriting and new pricing based on your current age and health. This page is focused on in-force policy options after an increase, but it is still worth talking to a licensed professional if you are considering replacing coverage.
If I take reduced paid-up, can I ever restart the original policy?
Usually no. Reduced paid-up is typically a one-way election. Make sure you understand the final benefit amount and whether inflation protection continues before you choose it.
What if I am already on claim?
Ask the insurer how the increase applies to policies already paying benefits and whether your choices are different while you are on claim. This varies by contract and state, so do not assume. Get the answer in writing.
My next step if you have the notice
- Call the insurer and ask for a side-by-side summary of every option offered: keep as-is, reduce daily or monthly benefit, reduce inflation, shorten benefit period or pool, and any nonforfeiture or reduced paid-up choices.
- Ask for projected benefits at a specific age (like 80 or 85) under each option.
- Choose what you can sustain without wrecking your monthly budget. The best policy is the one you can keep in force.
If you are unsure, bring the notice and your current policy page to a licensed LTC agent or a fee-only financial planner and ask them to walk you through the trade-offs using your exact numbers. A 20-minute review can help you avoid the kind of quiet cut you do not notice until you actually need care.